Young Family in Park

Find Your Ontario Mutual

Ontario Mutuals are independent, 100% Canadian, property and casualty insurance companies. They have a rich history, dating back over 160 years. They started out with simple fire insurance and became sophisticated companies, offering a variety of home, auto, commercial and farm insurance products.

Find Ontario Mutuals Across the Province!

Hover over a logo for contact details.

BCM

www.bcminsurance.com

1003 Niagara Street  

Welland, ON  L3C 1M5  

905-735-1234

BCM Logo

Brant Mutual

www.brantmutual.com

20 Holiday Drive

Brantford, ON N3R 7J4 

519-752-0088

Brant Mutual Logo

Amherst Island Mutual

R.R. # 1
Stella, ON K0H 2S0 

613-389-2012

Amherst Island Logo

Algoma Mutual

www.amico.ca

131 Main Street
Thessalon, ON P0R 1L0

705-842-3345

Algoma Mutual Logo

Dufferin Mutual

www.dufferinmutual.com

802 Main Street East Unit # 4, Shelburne  ON L9V 2Z5 

519-925-2026

Dufferin Mutual Logo

The Commonwell Mutual

www.thecommonwell.ca

336 Angeline Street South Lindsay, ON K9V 4R8

705-324-2146

Commonwell Mutual Logo

Caradoc Townsend Mutual

www.ctmins.ca

780 Old Highway 24 Waterford, ON N0E 1Y0 

519-443-7231

Caradoc Townsend Mutual Logo

Ayr Farmers Mutual

www.ayrmutual.com

1400 Northumberland Street Ayr, ON N0B 1E0  

519-632-7413

Ayr Farmers Mutual Logo

Dumfries Mutual

www.dumfriesmutual.com

1310 Old Hwy. # 8

Sheffield, ON L0R 1Z0 

519-621-4660

Dumfries Mutual Logo

Cayuga Mutual

www.cayugamutual.com

23 King Street 
Cayuga, ON N0A 1E0  

905-772-5498

Cayuga Mutual Logo

Bay of Quinte Mutual

www.bayofquintemutual.com

13379 Loyalist Parkway

Picton, ON K0K 2T0

613-476-2145

Bay of Quinte Logo

Edge Mutual

www.edgemutual.com

103 Wellington Street South Drayton, ON N0G 1P0  

519-638-3304

Edge Mutual Logo

Grenville Mutual

www.grenvillemutual.com

380 Colonnade Drive  Kemptville, ON K0G 1J0 

613-258-9988

Grenville Mutual Logo

Germania Mutual

www.germaniamutual.com

403 Mary Street, Ayton, ON N0G 1C0 

519-665-7715

Germania Mutual Logo

Erie Mutual

www.eriemutual.com

711 Main Street East Dunnville, ON N1A 2W5 

905-774-8566

Erie Mutual Logo

Halwell Mutual

www.halwellmutual.com

535 Hanlon Creek Blvd, Guelph, ON N1C 0A1 

519-836-2860

Halwell Mutual Logo

Howard Mutual

www.howardmutual.com

20 Ebenezer Street West, Ridgetown  ON NOP 2C0 

519-674-5434

Howard Mutual Logo

Heartland Farm Mutual

www.heartlandfarmmutual.com

100 Erb Street East Waterloo, ON N2J 1L9  

519-886-4530

Heartland Mutual Logo

HT & C Mutual

www.htcmutual.ca

37868 Zurich-Hensall Road, Zurich ON N0M 2T0 

519-236-4381

Howick Mutual

www.howickmutual.com

40592 Amberley Rd, RR # 4 Wingham, ON N0G 2W0 

519-912-1030

Howick Mutual Logo

McKillop Mutual

www.mckillopmutual.com

91 Main Street South 
Seaforth, ON N0K 1W0 

519-527-0400

McKillop Mutual

Middlesex Mutual

www.middlesexmutual.on.ca

15 Meredith Drive,

Ilderton ON N0M 2A0 

519-666-0075

Middlesex Logo

North Blenheim Mutual

www.northblenheim.com

11 Baird Street North

Bright, ON N0J 1B0

519-454-8661

North Blenheim Mutual Logo

L & A Mutual

www.l-amutual.com

32 Mill Street East,

Napanee ON K7R 1H2 

613-354-4810

L&A Mutual Logo

Kent & Essex Mutual

www.kemutual.com

10 Creek Road 
Chatham, ON N7M 5J3

519-352-3190

Kent and Essex Mutual Logo

HTM

www.htminsurance.ca

1185 Elgin Street West, Cobourg, ON K9A 4K5 

519-740-6415

HTM Logo

Nova Mutual

www.novamutual.com

33 Park Road

Simcoe, ON N3Y 4L5  

519-426-1294

Nova Mutual Logo

Peel Mutual

www.peelmutual.com

103 Queen Street West Brampton, ON L6Y 1M3 

519-655-2011

Peel Mutual Logo

South Easthope Mutual

www.southeasthope.com

62 Woodstock Street South, Tavistock, ON N0B 2R0 

519-655-2011

South-Easthope Mutual Logo

Lambton Mutual

www.lambtonmutual.com

7873 Confederation Line, Watford  ON NOM 2S0 

519-876-2304

Lambton Mutual Logo

North Kent Mutual

www.nkminsurance.com

29553 St. George Street, Dresden ON N0P 1M0 

519-683-4484

North Kent Mutual Logo

HT & C Mutual
www.htcmutual.ca

79 Caradoc Street North Strathroy, ON N7G 2M5 

519-246-1132

HTC Mutual Logo

Tradition Mutual

www.traditionmutual.com

264 Huron Road, PO Box 10
Sebringville, ON N0K 1X0 

519-393-6402

Tradition Mutual Logo

Trillium Mutual

www.trilliummutual.com

495 Mitchell Road South Listowel, ON N4W 0C8  

519-655-2011

Trillium Mutual Logo

Usborne & Hibbert Mutual

www.usborneandhibbert.ca

507 Main Street South

Exeter, ON N0M 1S1 

519-235-0350

Usborne and Hibbert Mutual Logo

West Elgin Mutual

www.westelgin.com

29584 Pioneer Line

Dutton, ON N0L 1J0

519-762-3530

west elgin mutual logo

Westminster Mutual

www.wmic.ca

14122 Belmont Road, Belmont, ON N0L 1B0  

519-644-1663

westminster mutual logo

West Wawanosh Mutual

www.wwmic.com

81 Southampton Street R.R. #1, Dungannon ON N0M 1R0  

519-529-7921

west wawanosh logo

Yarmouth Mutual

www.yarmouthmutual.com

1229 Talbot Street 
St. Thomas, ON N5P 1G8 

519-631-1572

Yarmouth Mutual Logo
Canadian Landscape

Outside of Ontario?

Find our other friendly mutuals in these parts of Canada:

Antigonish Farmers Mutual, Antigonish, Nova Scotia

Carleton Fundy Mutual, Sussex, New Brunswick

Clare Mutual, Belliveau Cove, Nova Scotia

Germania Mutual, Langenburg, Saskatchewan

Heartland Mutual, Berwick, Nova Scotia

Mennonite Mutual, Calgary, Alberta

My Mutual, Waldheim, Saskatchewan

PEI Mutual, Summerside, PEI

Portage Mutual, Portage La Prairie, Manitoba

Saskatchewan Mutual, Saskatoon, Saskatchewan

SouthEastern Mutual, Riverview, New Brunswick

Stanley Mutual, Stanley, New Brunswick

United General, Fredericton, New Brunswick

Ontario Mutuals Logo: We're in this together