Find Your Ontario Mutual
Ontario Mutuals are independent, 100% Canadian, property and casualty insurance companies. They have a rich history, dating back over 160 years. They started out with simple fire insurance and became sophisticated companies, offering a variety of home, auto, commercial and farm insurance products.
Find Ontario Mutuals Across the Province!
Hover over a logo for contact details.
Amherst Island Mutual
R.R. # 1
Stella, ON K0H 2S0
613-389-2012
Dufferin Mutual
802 Main Street East Unit # 4, Shelburne ON L9V 2Z5
519-925-2026
The Commonwell Mutual
336 Angeline Street South Lindsay, ON K9V 4R8
705-324-2146
Bay of Quinte Mutual
13379 Loyalist Parkway
Picton, ON K0K 2T0
613-476-2145
​
Heartland Farm Mutual
100 Erb Street East Waterloo, ON N2J 1L9
519-886-4530
South Easthope Mutual
62 Woodstock Street South, Tavistock, ON N0B 2R0
​
Tradition Mutual
264 Huron Road, PO Box 10
Sebringville, ON N0K 1X0
519-393-6402
​
Trillium Mutual
495 Mitchell Road South Listowel, ON N4W 0C8
519-655-2011
​
Usborne & Hibbert Mutual
507 Main Street South
Exeter, ON N0M 1S1
519-235-0350
Outside of Ontario?
Find our other friendly mutuals in these parts of Canada:
Antigonish Farmers Mutual, Antigonish, Nova Scotia
Carleton Fundy Mutual, Sussex, New Brunswick
Clare Mutual, Belliveau Cove, Nova Scotia
Germania Mutual, Langenburg, Saskatchewan
Heartland Mutual, Berwick, Nova Scotia
Mennonite Mutual, Calgary, Alberta
My Mutual, Waldheim, Saskatchewan
PEI Mutual, Summerside, PEI
Portage Mutual, Portage La Prairie, Manitoba
Saskatchewan Mutual, Saskatoon, Saskatchewan
SouthEastern Mutual, Riverview, New Brunswick
Stanley Mutual, Stanley, New Brunswick
United General, Fredericton, New Brunswick
